1035. ‘Maneater’, by Nelly Furtado

Since we started covering the 21st century, and probably before that, I will often mention a ‘modern sounding pop song.’ Britney, Christina, Sugababes, Kylie, and Beyoncé have all released ‘modern sounding pop songs’ over the past six years. But is Nelly Furtado’s the biggest ‘modern sounding pop song’ of them all?

Maneater, by Nelly Furtado (her 1st of two #1s)

3 weeks, from 11th June – 2nd July 2006

‘Maneater’ sounds like what pop music will sound like for the next five, if not ten, years. This is something Lady Gaga or Kesha could easily have released in 2011. I’d go as far as saying that this is what pop music will sound like until streaming comes along and makes everything boring. But more on that in good time.

A big part of this record’s modernity is having Timbaland on production duties, as he, along with Pharrell Williams, was setting the tone for pop over the following years. ‘Maneater’ was actually his second UK #1, after Aaliyah’s ‘More Than a Woman’ four years earlier, but it feels like the first. It has his signature chunky, stuttery synths all over it, as well as the man himself mumbling throughout.

He claims to have used the Hall & Oates’ track of the same name as an influence, though the two don’t sound overly similar. Maybe in the very deliberate beat? (Daryll Hall has a differing opinion, claiming that this song was theft!) It is definitely a very eighties-adjacent track, though, with the synths updated for the mid-2000s.

What of the singer, Nelly Furtado? This was a big departure from the folksy, kooky pop of her first two albums. ‘I’m Like a Bird’ had been a huge hit in 2001, much bigger than its #5 peak suggests. But since then she’d struggled for traction, in Britain at least. ‘Maneater’ changed all that, as did follow-up ‘Promiscuous’, recasting her as a femme fatale. The way she speaks of her biggest hit, comparing it to eating too much cheesecake, and calling it ‘in your face… bitchy and loud’, sounds to me like she wasn’t fully sold on it.

That’s the thing about ‘Maneater’. I like it, and it is confronting and catchy, but there isn’t much there. I can’t explain it. In a very specific setting – loud, and in a nightclub – it will sound great. But at its heart it’s just Timbaland picking the biggest, juiciest synths, and Nelly Furtado slutting it up. Which is exactly what you might say about Christina Aguilera’s ‘Dirrty’, and that’s a song I love and named as a Very Best. Who knows why? Maybe Nelly Furtado’s heart just wasn’t in it as much as Xtina’s was…?

The last minute of the song is an interesting, more EDM influenced coda that I don’t think was on the single edit (which is missing from Spotify), or was skipped by radio at the time. It’s cool, though, and it’s a bit of shame that the main body of the song doesn’t sound more like it.

It’s also a shame for this song that, just as it was looking like a sure-fire pick for song of the summer, another female singer on the comeback trail turned up and bettered it. Next time, on number ones blog.

Just the music…

Advertisements

One thought on “1035. ‘Maneater’, by Nelly Furtado”

  1. I’m sorry. Other than the title, I have a hard time recognizing similarities between Nelly Furtado’s and Hall & Oates’ ‘Maneater.’ As such, I’m not sure why Daryl Hall would call it ‘theft’ other than perhaps to generate some PR for himself. All looks a bit silly to me.

Leave a Reply