From the sublime to the heinous…
I Wish I Was a Punk Rocker (With Flowers in My Hair), by Sandi Thom (her 1st and only #1)
1 week, from 4th – 11th June 2006
From Gnarls Barkley’s nine-week classic, to this little sneak-a-week slice of garbage. Maybe I should introduce a policy where the amount I write about a song is commensurate to how long they stayed at number one? Which would mean I could quickly skip over tracks like this. But then it would also mean I didn’t have the word count to properly lay into them…
When Natasha Bedingfield made #1 with the bad (but nowhere near as bad as this) ‘These Words’, I introduced the new genre ‘posh girl pop’. As in somewhat kooky posh girls making edgeless, soulless, pointless pop. Sandi Thom is from Banff, Aberdeenshire, admittedly not an overly posh part of Scotland, but she did go to stage school (and was the youngest student ever admitted into the Liverpool Institute for Performing Arts). Which makes sense, as this song has big stage school energy.
It’s musically odd, perhaps even original. It’s essentially an a cappella song, backed by clapping, banging, and the odd tambourine. It’s Mumford and Sons come half a decade early. Not many number ones have sounded like this, and so if it this record to get any points at all it will be for that. The music is not what I take exception to here, though…
The title, which doubles as the opening line, tells you everything you need to know about this tripe. Oh I wish I was a punk rocker with flowers in my hair… Okay, yes, I do see what Thom’s going for. She’s combining flower-power and punk, and even she would have known that this was ironic. Fine. She gets the dates wrong, because by 1969 the hippy dream had largely died, but maybe the line when God saved the queen she turned a whiter shade of pale is funny, to some people.
What is truly abhorrent about this song is that it reads like one of those Facebook nostalgia pages. You know, the ones called ‘Who remembers proper binmen?’ or ‘Hands up if you were a kid in the seventies’, that celebrate Britain ‘back then’, with all the dodgy, unspoken connotations that that brings up. Thom reminisces on letters in the mail, footballers with dirt on their faces, kids wearing hand-me-downs, when ignorance could still be bliss (??)… Okay, she couldn’t have predicted modern, slightly racist, social media nostalgia-fests when she wrote it, but unfortunately for her this type of nostalgia has become weaponised in the last couple of decades.
Anyway, the very, very worst thing about this song is that Sandi Thom is the exact thing she is complaining about in the lyrics. When the media couldn’t buy your soul… When computers were still scary… When pop stars remained a myth… are all things she reminisces on. Yet Thom came to prominence thanks to Myspace (thanks computers!) and webcasts of her performing from her basement (so much for pop stars remaining a myth, I don’t think we ever saw Bowie’s basement!). While some claimed that she had a suspiciously large publicity campaign behind her, including a million virtual flyers AKA spam emails (well done on the media not buying your soul, Sandi…)
As I write this paragraph, I’m on my sixth listen of ‘I Wish I Was…’ and each play confirms that this is utter, utter garbage. The worst. A shoe-in for my next Worst #1 award. It makes the ‘JCB Song’ sound fun. One more listen and I might go insane. It’ll have been nice knowing you. Let’s wrap this post up quickly.
Sandi Thom had one further Top 40 hit – ‘What If I’m Right’ – but continues to tour and record to this day. The album this came from is called ‘Smile… It Confuses People’, which is the sort of garbage the goths at my high school might have come out with on a slow day. She remains particularly popular in Australia where, and I had to do a triple-take when I read this, ‘I Wish I Was a Punk Rocker…’ stayed at #1 for ten weeks. That’s ten… 10… X… weeks.
Strewth.




















