1029. ‘Sorry’, by Madonna

Our third disco influenced number one in a row. And leave it to Madame Ciccone to show them all how it’s properly done…

Sorry, by Madonna (her 12th of thirteen #1s)

1 week, from 26th February – 5th March 2006

The question I’d like address before we finish today is thus: Is ‘Sorry’ better than ‘Hung Up’? Answers at the end of the post. The two records are cut from the same cloth, at least. This is a little more laidback, more electro/new-wave than its predecessor, more reliant on synths and bass than strings and an ABBA sample. But it is still a great dance tune.

Lyrically, it’s the flip-side of ‘Hung Up’. In the earlier hit, Madonna was largely gagging for an unnamed man. Calling him on the phone and being both literally and metaphorically ‘hung up’. On ‘Sorry’, though, she is reading the riot act, in a very disco-diva fashion. Don’t explain yourself, ‘Cause talk is cheap, There’s more important things than hearing you speak… is a great line, as is the withering: You’re not half the man you’d like to be…

And yes, it’s another shadow #1, following in the wake of an even bigger hit, like so many chart-toppers were in the low sales climate of 2006, as Britain slowly transitioned from CDs to downloads. Casual physical purchases were dropping, and so having a fanbase like Madonna’s, willing to hit the aisles of HMV, was vital. But again, I don’t want to bandy terms like ‘shadow number one’, or the even less complimentary ‘non-number one’, around with songs as good as this.

Any song by Madonna automatically qualifies for gay anthem status. What nudges this record into camp classic territory is when Madge shows off her impressive polyglotism, by reciting the title in various languages. And as a very (very) low-level speaker of Japanese, the one thing I can pull Madonna up on here is for getting the stress completely wrong on gomenasai.

But hell, it’s Madonna. If she wants to pronounce it wrong then Japan will just have adjust its language to suit. I love this song, I love Madonna. But. Is ‘Sorry’ better than ‘Hung Up’? Well, I am enjoying it today, especially because you don’t hear it half as much as its predecessor, but all in all, no. ‘Hung Up’ is the better track. Though this was a hell of a one-two for an artist over three decades into her career.

Advertisements

6 thoughts on “1029. ‘Sorry’, by Madonna”

  1. I definitely have heard this song before as I’ve listened to this album several times, but I wasn’t remembering it until the first verse and then it immediately clicked. Very catchy chorus. I don’t think this makes No. 1 without it being January and benefitting from the low January sales though.

    I like Madonna in many of her incarnations (I liked when she went more R&B with Bedtimes Stories for example and I even liked when she was desperately trying to chase relevance in the late-2010s with her trap-pop/reggaeton phase), but she’s at her best when she does dance music. I thought Confessions II was awesome. Between it, the Stones new album and Sir Paul McCartney’s new albums, this has been a great year for music veterans. Even Deep Purple’s new album was pretty solid.

    I just checked and her last (at least at this moment, she could get another No. 1) No. 1 was a duet with Justin Timberlake (the American Robbie Williams), who I won’t spoil, but I have a lot to say about as an artist when we get to him and particularly the difference between his former boy band’s success in the UK compared to his.

    I normally try to not to discuss an artists’ look, but I remember as a kid thinking Madonna looked really striking – I wouldn’t have used the word sexy or hot as I was too young I think I was 5 when this song came out for that but now I can say she was sexy and hot and like a MILF – in this era (this was my first real awareness of Madonna as an artist). Looking at her from my adult self, she looked very good and fit for her age and was aging quite gracefully with only the lightest touch of plastic surgery (like Anne Hathaway nowadays) before she spent most of the 2010s and early 2020s looking like an alien, though she returned back to normalcy now.

    • This made number one at the end of Feb, but I guess your point still stands. Its sales weren’t especially low (37k to make #1 when many records at the time were doing so with sales below 30k) but I definitely think it made the top by basking in the glow of ‘Hung Up’.

      In many ways this would have been the perfect moment for her to bow out from chart-topping, as I don’t rate ‘4 Minutes’. But who knows? Maybe she does have one more #1 in her? A duet with Olivia Rodrigo or Sabrina Carpenter…? Madonna’s actually had more UK Top 10s in the 2020s (2) than she had for the entire 2010s (zero). One of them was this year’s Kylie duet on ‘Love Sensation’, in which the two icons made every middle-aged gay man’s Christmas come early.

      • Oh yeah, February, sorry I don’t know why I said January. And funnily enough, she actually has a duet with Sabrina Carpenter on her new album that was the lead single “Bring Your Love” which got to #29 in the UK. Even as a straight man, but as an Aussie who loves pop music and is proud of Princess Kylie, that Kylie + Madonna collab was a dream come true.

        I think honestly Madonna will only score another No. 1 as a solo artist posthumously, unfournately. Or if she manages to get Olivia Rodrigo + Sabrina Carpenter as featured artists, due to how quite momentunal that would be considering the tension and unquashed beef between Rodrigo and Carpenter. Or someone like Taylor Swift who seems to be able to get to No. 1 without trying all by herself. She’ll need to rely on featured artists – she won’t be able to make No. 1 by herself, she’s firmly a legacy artist now as much as she doesn’t want to admit it. And it’s ok to be a legacy artist.

      • Yeah it’s strange the difference Madonna ft. Sabrina Carpenter vs if it had been Sabrina Carpenter ft. Madonna. The latter would have a chance at #1, especially if it was the lead from a new album. Who knows…?

        I just can’t see TS doing a duet with Madonna, or Madonna duetting with TS. Who would be the feature?? I can’t see either of them playing second fiddle.

  2. Hung Up is the better of the 2 but Sorry is a great dancepop track too, Madonna had a bunch of number ones off Confessions I in my personal charts, boosted by seeing that tour in Cardiff. She did well dancing about still, though had a bunch of other dancers distracting at appropriate places to catch her breath. I’m the same age as Madonna and I’m pretty sure I couldnt have done that for 2 hours!

Leave a Reply