Today’s Top 10 – March 31st, 1970

A Happy Easter to all who celebrate it. I’m launching a new feature this Easter Sunday, something to enjoy while rendered immobile by one too many chocolate eggs… ‘Today’s Top 10’! My blog focuses very intently on every song that’s made #1 in the UK, and I often try to draw conclusions on how popular music has been shaped, and has shifted, over the years based on one tune alone. Which is actually quite limiting, because the singles charts have always been about more than just the number one. Over the 70-plus years of the singles chart, we’ve had a weekly Top 12, a Top 30, a Top 40, a Top 75, and now a Top 100.

So I want to, every so often, single out a random Top 10 from history, to look at in more detail. My version of ‘Pick of the Pops’, if you will. Cue the music….! Completely at random, using an online date generator, the first to come out the hat was 1970: the singles chart as it stood fifty-four years ago today. It features, inevitably, a #1 we’ve met before (plus one former #1), as well as songs by some of the biggest acts of all time. So let’s crack on…

#10 – ‘Don’t Cry Daddy’, by Elvis Presley (down 1 / 6 weeks on chart)

The early-seventies was a sort of musical wilderness: after the post-sixties comedown, a year or so out from the glam rock takeover of 1972-73. Speaking of musical wildernesses, here’s Elvis with a maudlin ballad about a break-up (or is it a mother’s death?) written from the POV of the couple’s daughter. Elvis croons the life out of it, and that voice could sell anything, but even he struggles to imbue lines like Daddy you’ve still got me and little Tommy, Together we’ll find a brand new mommy… with any sort of gravitas. He was still capable of greatness in the early seventies – in a few months he’d be back on top with one of his biggest hits, ‘The Wonder of You’ – but this is pretty saccharine.

#9 – ‘Everybody Get Together’, by The Dave Clark Five (down 1 / 5 weeks on chart)

The DC5 had scored their one and only #1, the stomping ‘Glad All Over’, more than six years earlier. So it is impressive that they were still hanging around the Top 10, when so many of their ’60s contemporaries had already faded away. This is a call-to-arms, a song with a message: Everybody get together, Try to love one another right now… Originally written as a folk song, and a hit in 1967 for the Youngbloods at the height of flower-power, The Dave Clark Five clearly felt that the sentiment was worth one more go. But there’s a droning, heavy feel to this version that feels weary, as if they’ve given up on the message even before the end of the song. It’s appropriately downbeat, perhaps, for the end of the sixties and the start of an uncertain new decade. Fitting too, as this was the Five’s final Top 10 hit. They would disband by the end of the year.

#8 – ‘Something’s Burning’, by Kenny Rogers & The First Edition (up 3 / 9 weeks on chart)

New to this week’s Top 10, and maintaining our run of hits by artists that we’ve already met in the #1 position, it’s Kenny Rogers and The First Edition with a sexy, sexy song. The verses are soft and slinky, lines like You lie in gentle sleep beside me, I hear your warm and rhythmic breathing… but it builds to a heated crescendo in the chorus. Kenny growls Here it comes, Can’t you feel it baby… and we know he’s not talking about the No. 42 bus. Lord have mercy…! It’s a world away from his much more gentle, much more ‘country’, solo hits like ‘Lucille’.

#7 – ‘Let It Be’, by The Beatles (down 3 / 4 weeks on chart)

Some of you may have heard this one before… The last single released before Paul McCartney’s departure heralded the end of history’s greatest group. There’s nothing new I can say about the record as a whole, so I’ll single out my two personal favourite moments. George Harrison’s snarling solo (especially on the album version) and the way Paul’s scouse accent sneaks through in the word ‘trouble’. Perhaps I’m just used to the streaming age, where songs hang around the charts for……ever, but for a song as legendary as ‘Let it Be’ not to make #1, and then be slipping down to #7 after just four weeks, seems surprising.

#6 – ‘That Same Old Feeling’, by Pickettywitch (down 1 / 6 weeks on chart)

I can’t say I’ve ever heard this one, though it had been as high as #5. It’s a nice enough, Motown-leaning tune done in a late-sixties, bubblegum style. Pickettywitch – I can’t decide if that’s a great or a terrible name – are another sign that though we may be in March of 1970, we’re still in the sixties going by much of this Top 10. Lead singer Polly Brown has a decent voice, reminding me of Diana Ross.

#5 – ‘Young, Gifted and Black’, by Bob & Marcia (up 1 / 4 weeks on chart)

I’ve made many a reference to the fact that reggae is the most indestructible of genres on the UK singles chart. Never the defining sound of an age, but always popping up when you least expect it. In 1970, it really was a new sound, Desmond Dekker having scored the first ‘official’ reggae #1 (if you ignore The Equals, and ‘Ob La Di…’) the year before. This is reggae + , with lots of strings, and rocking drums, but I’d say it still counts. More significant, though, are the lyrics: In the whole world I know, There’s a million boys and girls, That are young, gifted and black… And that’s a fact! Written and originally recorded by Nina Simone a few months earlier, right at the end of the decade that had brought the Civil Rights Movement to a head, for this to make the Top 10 in the UK feels very significant, and the second song in this rundown that could be described as a ‘rallying cry’.

#4 – ‘Wand’rin’ Star’, by Lee Marvin (down 2 / 9 weeks on chart)

A former number one – which I go into much more detail on here – that had kept ‘Let It Be’ from top spot a few weeks before. It was taken from the movie version of ‘Paint Your Wagon’, which was a box office flop. A bizarre #1 at the start of a decade full of bizarre #1s, Lee Marvin officially has the lowest voice ever heard on a chart-topping single (*disclaimer – may not be true*), and uses it brilliantly on this anti-social anthem: I never seen a sight that didn’t look better lookin’ back…

#3 – ‘Can’t Help Falling in Love’, by Andy Williams (non-mover / 4 weeks on chart)

Elvis makes a second appearance in the Top 10, in spirit at least, with Andy Williams’ belting cover of the King’s 1962 #1, ‘Can’t Help Falling in Love’. If it was impressive that the DC5 were still having hits in 1970, then we should also give a nod to the fact that Williams debuted with ‘Butterfly’ – his sole chart-topper – in 1957. But then again, crooners like Williams are timeless, much less prey to shifting trends than pop groups. The video above, which I think comes from later in the decade, is a spectacular glimpse into ’70s variety shows: the multi-coloured steps, the giant ‘ANDY’, the cardigan…

#2 – ‘Knock, Knock Who’s There?’, by Mary Hopkin (up 5 / 2 weeks on chart)

Venture deep enough into a springtime chart, and there’s a good chance you’ll meet a Eurovision Song Contest entry. ‘Knock, Knock Who’s There?’ was the UK’s 1970 offering, finishing second on the night to Ireland’s Dana. This is very schmaltzy, very middle of the road – not a patch on Hopkin’s huge breakthrough #1 ‘Those Were the Days’ – but it’s a darn sight better than the horrible ‘All Kinds of Everything’. This was a big departure from Hopkin’s usual, folky offerings, and she wasn’t a fan: “I was so embarrassed about it. Standing on stage singing a song you hate is just awful.” Hate it though she might have, it brought about her final Top 10 hit.

#1 – ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’, Simon & Garfunkel – (non-mover / 7 weeks on chart)

In the middle of a three-week run at the top, ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’ was just the 3rd number one of the 1970s, but is probably one of the decade’s biggest and best-loved songs. Simon wrote it, while Garfunkel gave one of the great vocal performances (something that apparently irks Paul to this day…) You can read my original post here.

In a way, ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’ is the perfect number one for this chart. March 1970 wasn’t the sixties, but it’s wasn’t the seventies as we remember it either. ‘Bridge…’ is timeless, not beholden to many of the styles of the time, and could have been a #1 at most points in chart history. Elsewhere in the Top 10, we tick a few common chart boxes: soundtrack hits, Eurovision, Elvis, The Beatles… Maybe the two most relevant songs, though, are ‘Everybody Get Together’, and ‘Young, Gifted and Black’, which represent the social and civil rights movements that had defined the latter part of the 1960s. The hippy dream may have died, Dr King may have been killed, but hope springs eternal…

That was fun, and hopefully worthwhile. I’ll do another one sometime, as a break from our normal proceedings. Next up it’s back to 1996…

10 thoughts on “Today’s Top 10 – March 31st, 1970

  1. That seems an oddly middle-of-the-road Top 10 from 1970, and it’s funny to think it was the year we were getting some pretty major rock hit singles from time to time (cue Canned Heat, Jethro Tull, Free, Deep Purple, Hendrix and others). I’d happily pass on Lee Marvin, also what was one of Elvis’ worst even by his standards, but most of the others are the more acceptable side of easy listening. I’d agree though that George Harrison’s superb sealing guitar solo was really the making of ‘Let It Be’ and ’Something’s Burning’ was probably Kenny Rogers’ finest moment, though he’s an artist I’ve grown to have more of a soft spot for with the years – likewise Andy Williams. But ‘Bridge Over Troubled Water’ and ‘Young, Gifted and Black’ are probably the most timeless records in this batch. Oh, we probably thought nothing of it at the time, but that picture of the Dave Clark Five with those kids apparently wrapped up in oversize ponchos with them, isn’t there something a bit not quite right about that…(and I heard it on the radio the other day for the first time in ages, I liked it at the time but it struck me as rather repetitive, as if they’d gone for a ‘Hey Jude’-style interminable ending because they’d run out of ideas as to where to go next)

    >

    • I did think that when I saw the Dave Clark Five album cover… Very 1970s, knowing what we know now… (not the DC5, though, before anyone sues!) And I agree that theirs is a strange cover of the song, sucking the life out what is a very positive message… But I think it’s a symptom of the post-60s comedown, maybe. Next time I do this, I’ll try to conjur up a more rocking Top 10!

  2. You should do this type of random year/week Top 10 every once and while, especially since it would allow you to cover some artists (and even whole genres) that didn’t get to No. 1 (or got to No. 1 with their lesser songs like Stevie Wonder and Paul McCartney or the entire hard rock and heavy metal genres) but had some Top 10 representation.

    Like, Black Sabbath of all bands had a UK No. 4 hit in 1970 with “Paranoid” (love that video seeing teenagers dance to “Paranoid” on Top of the Pops while the band is miming the song and Ozzy is giving a vocal performance better than the original recording).

    • Yeah I think I’ll do one every few months, see what it turns up! And as another poster said, I was quite unlucky with this middle of the road chart, as the early seventies was probably as rock-oriented as the British charts ever got

  3. Various songs on here I didn’t know. I also didn’t realize the DC5 covered “Everybody Get Together”. While I prefer the rendition by The Youngbloods, DC5 passed the audition. I also like “Can’t Help Falling in Love”, though cannot say the same about the Andy Williams cover. And, yes, it’s hard to imagine there’s somebody with a deeper voice than Lee Marvin! 🙂

  4. good idea doing this, keeps up the interest for anyone not so fussed about the 90’s! 1970 for me was about pop, soul, reggae, easy listening, poprock and a little bit of Metal now and again. It was more for older music fans who could afford albums – kids most certainly couldnt afford albums till they started getting money from (in my case) baby sitting, newspaper deliveries or whatever as they turned 14 or 15, or birthdays and xmas cash from relatives. So it was all about singles on a day to day basis, and pop still ruled.

    Records I loved at the time? Lee Marvin, Beatles, Simon & Garfunkel in that order probably – 50 years on the order is reversed, with Lee dropping behind Bob & Marcia (a 1974 discovery for me, timeless record). I knew and liked Mary Hopkin’s but it’s not up to her first 3 classic pop tracks. The rest I got to hear in 1975 on the 5 Years Ago chart show hosted by an unmentionable – and I taped the ones I liked the sound of. That would be The Dave Clark 5, fab song – though the original is better, a 90’s discovery for me. Elvis’ was rubbish still hate it. Andy’s version of Can’t Help Falling In Love was way livelier than Elvis’ (and more fun). Pickettywich is quite nice, but I knew her better as Polly Brown of Sweet Dreams Abba-hitmakers (Honey Honey) by then. I recall a singles reviewer giving the game away talking about this mysterious new singer called Sara Leone or something and said there are rumours of someone else and you can pick o’ t’ which rumour you fancy…

  5. Well I love this feature…you never would have guessed that! I haven’t done it in a while…but since I started to follow you…I have compared Billboard to the UK at times…I can’t believe the differences.

    Anyway… I never knew Mary Hopkin ended that quick. I liked her song “Goodbye” alot…but I like McCartney’s demo more. The one that surprises me is the Dave Clark Five…they lasted longer than I thought.
    And yea…one of George’s best solos.

      • Good…it’s cool to see the complete top ten and of that era…there are always songs that are classic it seems like.

Leave a reply to christiansmusicmusings Cancel reply