900. ‘Lady Marmalade’, by Christina Aguilera, Lil’ Kim, Mýa & Pink

We are officially 900 number ones not out! Thanks to everyone who has ever read, commented, liked and followed. I’m not sure that I ever imagined when I started writing these posts back in November 2017 (!) that I’d ever get this far. But, to paraphrase an old football cliché, I’ve just been taking it one number one at a time…

Lady Marmalade, by Christina Aguilera (her 2nd of four #1s), Lil Kim, Mýa & Pink (her 1st of three #1s)

1 week, from 24th June – 1st July 2001

Our 900th is not the most original of chart-toppers, a cover of ‘Lady Marmalade’ coming barely three years on from the last chart-topping cover of ‘Lady Marmalade’. Have two other versions of the same song ever made #1 so close together? Anyway, while All Saints’ take played fast and loose with the LaBelle original, this all-star re-imagining is much more faithful.

One big difference, though, is that Lady Marmalade no longer plies her trade down in old New Orleans. She’s been transferred to the Moulin Rouge in Paris, just in time for the big glossy Baz Luhrmann movie musical of the same name. Different brothel, same story. Kitchy kitchy kitchy yaya dada. Mocha chocolatey yaya… Voulez-vous coucher avec moi ce soir?

It would be easy to look down on this OTT, fairly superfluous take on a seventies classic, in which four bad-ass chicks from the Moulin Rouge try to out-diva one another. And I won’t claim that it is better than LaBelle’s. But I enjoyed it back in 2001, and I still do enjoy it now. It strips all subtlety from what was already a fairly unsubtle song, adds a grinding industrial synth riff, and some well-placed cowbells. Mýa warms things up with the first verse, Pink (feeling quite out of place here, and in her suspenders in the video) ups the ante with the second. Clearly things were being set up for Christina, by far the biggest name of the four at the time, to blow everything out of the water for the finish.

Except, for my money, the show is stolen by Lil Kim’s rapped verse, the song’s one big change from the original, in which she delivers the immortal line: We independent women, Some mistake us for whores, I say why spend mine, When I can spend yours…? It’s a very modern female rap, a full decade ahead of Nicki Minaj and Cardi B, that even Xtina’s explosive belting can’t overshadow. But boy, does she try. And it works, doesn’t grate, because, again, this ain’t the time for subtlety.

This record is a lot like the movie it came from, and like a lot Baz Luhrmann’s filmography: good fun, as long as you don’t stop and think about it too much. My biggest issue with it is why Missy (Misdemeanour here) Elliott, who acts as the MC for the outro, doesn’t get a credit, and therefore her second number one single?

It’s been customary, every hundred number ones, for me to look back at the marker posts that have gone before. But there’s a recap up next, and I’d like to save any retrospection for then. What is worth noting is how short the gaps between each hundred are getting. There were over seven years between the first chart-topper and the hundredth (November 1952 to April 1960), but less than three between numbers 800 and 900 (September 1998 to June 2001).

6 thoughts on “900. ‘Lady Marmalade’, by Christina Aguilera, Lil’ Kim, Mýa & Pink

  1. Agree on all counts – pretty much everything Luhrmann-related is best enjoyed when you not think about it too much, which also applies here.

    Mya > Lil’ Kim > (Missy) > Xtina > P!nk for me in this joint. I thought Mya opened the entire thing marvelously and she anchored every chorus very well (even if her vocals got pushed further back in the mix each time they announced a new vocalist). Lil’ Kim is obviously a delight as always, as is Missy with her cheeky Mr. Miller closing. Xtina and P!nk… a bit much of muchness, both of them, but again on the grand scheme of things they’re not unwelcome either.

    Excited for the recap! Rooting for the greatest house music of all time (Groovejet, naturally) to enter the Very Best list.

    • Ah well you might be disappointed by my choice for Very Best… Groovejet was close but I went much darker, shall we say…

      I really enjoy Xtina’s oversinging on this, as I think it actually fits the song for once. They’re meant to be outdoing one another. And wait, is Missy Elliott saying ‘Mr Miller here’ at the end?? I always thought it was ‘Misdemeanour here’, as in Missy ‘Misdemeanour’ Elliott!

  2. Not seen the film, I’m afraid, but my heart is still with Labelle, though I enjoyed the more subdued All Saints version. I think Christina’s OTT antics put me off this one, but she’ll have much better to come!

    • This isn’t Christina’s best number one, but I think it is the one where her belting is most suited. I’ve not heard Beautiful for a while, but I seem to remember she spoils that with oversinging.

Leave a reply to Anonymous Cancel reply