For the first time in a good nine months – since The Four Pennies’ bland ode to ‘Juliet’ – do we arrive at a #1 single that I have never heard before. This is how it used to be, of course, in the pre-rock days – before rock ‘n’ roll came along, with all those famous songs in tow. Almost every post was a step into the unknown…
I’ll Never Find Another You, by The Seekers (their 1st of two #1s)
2 weeks, from 25th February – 11th March 1965
Speaking of rock ‘n’ roll, and the fifties and all that… The opening chords of this latest chart-topper sound a lot like ‘La Bamba’. A mellower, more folksy version of the Ritchie Valens hit to be sure, but they’re there. It’s a promising opening… that lasts until the singers open their mouths…
There’s a new world somewhere, They call the promised land, And I’ll be there someday, If you could hold my hand… Several earnest, fresh-faced voices chime together. I’m getting strong Christians-round-a-campfire vibes… I still need you there beside me, No matter what I do, For I know I’ll never find another you… Or maybe proto-hippies, the first feelers of a movement that will go full-on mainstream in a couple of years? The lyrics sure do sound like they could be about joining a commune (‘The promised land’?)
Not quite. This record is, though, our first slice of sixties folk-rock. The gentle guitars, the clear vocals, the tambourine that gets a good shaking in the background… It’s a genre that I don’t think was ever quite as popular in the UK as in America, where Peter, Paul and Mary, The Byrds, The Mamas and the Papas, Simon & Garfunkel and, of course, Bob Dylan were big, big stars. But we’d had fair warning of it – remember back in 1961, when the collegiate folk band The Highwaymen scored a surprise #1 with their version of ‘Michael’ (Row Your Boat etc. etc.)? They were from across the pond, too.
I’m not convinced by this song, to be honest… There’s something a bit cloying about it, a bit happy-clappy. And the lead singer – Judith Durham – sounds kind of like a Sunday school teacher gone rogue. Plus the lyrics don’t really go anywhere – it’s just a long list of what she can do with her man by her side… When I walk through the storm you’ll be my guide… and I could lose it all tomorrow, And never mind at all… etcetera and so on. It’s not terrible; but it’s the worst number one for a while. Probably since ‘Juliet’, the last chart-topper that I’d never heard of… And in its defence, we’ve just enjoyed the highest-quality run of #1 singles in British chart-history, and it would be unfair to completely write a record off just because it doesn’t hit the heights of ‘A Hard Day’s Night’ or ‘You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feelin’.
I am, for example, a sucker for those yearning chords that pop up time and time again in folk-rock. See lines like You’ll be my someone, Forever and a day… Or If I should lose your love dear, I don’t know what I’ll do… The first song I ever loved – I’m reliably informed, as I was too young to remember – was ‘Puff the Magic Dragon’, which I would sing anywhere and everywhere as a toddler, driving everyone around me to the edge of insanity. And ‘Puff’’s got plenty of those yearning, minor-key chords in it. Who knows – maybe I’m a folky at heart?
Of course, all that stuff I just spouted about ‘I’ll Never Find Another You’ being an all-American slice of hippyish folk is undone by the fact that The Seekers were Australian, and that the song was composed by British songwriter Tom Springfield (brother of Dusty – who keeps cropping up via other people’s songs – when will she appear on her own merits?) But hey. It sounds American, and was definitely influenced by American folk-rock artists of the day, so we’re claiming it for the Yanks.
To finish, I’ll return to the pre-rock days that I mentioned at the start of the post. Back then, as Vera Lynn, Dickie Valentine, Winifred Atwell et al were jostling for attention at the top of the charts, the word I reached for more often than most was ‘twee’. And that’s what this is: the twee-est number one single we’ve had in a long time. Altogether then, grab the marshmallows and back round the campfire for another singalong!
Catch up with this handily compiled playlist!
13 thoughts on “188. ‘I’ll Never Find Another You’, by The Seekers”
This one I’ve never liked too much. I can’t put my finger on it really…I do like the melody but it’s the vocals…a little too clean maybe?
I think it’s a little too wholesome, a little too like a campfire singalong. I’m exactly the same – the melody is really catchy but the singers a bit too earnest
earnest is it…that is the word I was looking for…
Yeah. Like school kids trying hard, but just not cool enough
I was originally going to say square kids trying to be cool…
That’s it in a nutshell! We got there in the end…
OMG the beginning totally sounds like “La Bamba”! I noticed a lot of old songs have parts in them that sound exactly like other songs. I guess this was before all the lawsuits. They could’ve never gotten away with that in the 90’s. Anyway, after the “La Bamba” intro, it definitely changes into a kind of hippy commune type tune. I read the description before I listened to the song and you describe it well! 🙂
Thanks! I guess there’s always been a fine line between being ‘heavily influenced by’ and plain old copying. I think this intro just about gets a pass… It’s a cute song, but not one I’m desperate to hear again!
Pingback: 199. ‘Mr Tambourine Man’, by The Byrds – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 206. ‘The Carnival Is Over’, by The Seekers – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: Recap: #181 – #210 – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 308. ‘I’d Like to Teach the World to Sing (In Perfect Harmony)’, by The New Seekers – The UK Number Ones Blog
Totally disagree about this song.
The song got a very emotional load to me.
They played the song a couple of times on Laser 558 as classic track, back in the 80s.
I think this song got a deep and special spot in heart by millions of people in the UK.