Two years after their first #1 single, Tony and his ‘tache are back on top!
Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree, by Dawn ft. Tony Orlando (their 2nd and final #1)
4 weeks, from 15th April – 13th May 1973
Back in ’71, he was asking his girl to ‘Knock Three Times’ if she felt like hooking up, now he’s asking her to ‘Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree’ if she still loves him. He is evidently a man who needs things spelled out for him.
It starts with a tune that can certainly be described as ‘jaunty’. Yep, the dreaded ‘J’ word. It’s a melody that must be from something else, some old German schlager hit, so familiar does it sound. It sounds as if it’s been playing in the back of your mind for years and years and, now that you’ve brought it to the forefront, it’ll be going round and round in there for years to come.
I’m comin’ home, I’ve done my time… Tony’s been in prison for crimes undefined… Now I’ve got to know what is and isn’t mine… He’s written ahead, and given his girl instructions what to do if she’s still into him: Tie a yellow ribbon round the old oak tree, It’s been three long years, Do you still want me…? If he doesn’t see a ribbon, he’ll stay on the bus and make a new life wherever he winds up.
Yes, it is utter cheese. But it’s a cute concept, and the melody – that melody – is undeniable. There’s a simple reason why this was a huge worldwide smash: it’s pretty darn catchy. It gets a bit much in places – the harmonica solo, for example – but, as with ‘Knock Three Times’, Tony and co. just about get away with it.
The bus draws close to his hometown. The tension is too much, he can’t look and begs the driver to check for him. It reminds me of Tom Jones’s ‘Green, Green Grass of Home’ in that it’s about a convict returning home to those he loves. Except, in that song it was all just a dream and he’s about to get shot at dawn. This one has a much happier ending…
For in verse three, we slow down, Tony drags it out: Now the whole damn bus is cheerin’, And I can’t believe I see… A hundred yellow ribbons round the old oak tree! A hundred! She must have really missed him (and forgiven whatever crimes he may or may not have committed.) Hurrah!
As before, Tony O’s backing singers don’t have very much to do, but they are two different singers from the band’s earlier #1. The ‘classic’ Dawn line-up of Tony, Telma Hopkins and Joyce Vincent Wilson was in place by the time they released ‘Tie a Yellow Ribbon…’ They had a few more hits to come on the Billboard chart, and around the world (seriously, this is a band with huge appeal in non-English speaking countries, with their traditional melodies and simple lyrics) but in the UK this was their last really big one.
And no, surprisingly, this wasn’t based on the melody of some old German hit… It was fresh off the press – written in 1973 – though the idea of a loved one wearing yellow for the return of as soldier (or a convict) had been around in American folklore since the 1800s. Apparently the track was offered to Ringo Starr, but – and I love this – an Apple Records Exec. told the writers that they ‘should be ashamed of their ridiculous song’. What wasn’t good enough for Ringo was good enough for Sinatra, Perry Como, Dean Martin, Bing Crosby… basically any crooner worth their salt has covered it. It has, more seriously, been used as a protest anthem in the Philippines and Hong Kong, in which yellow ribbons have been symbols. So there! Dismiss this as fluff at your peril… Take it away, Tony, one last time…
18 thoughts on “329. ‘Tie a Yellow Ribbon Round the Ole Oak Tree’, by Dawn ft. Tony Orlando”
I love the story about the Ringo Starr (non-)connection. That Apple Records exec was doubtless looking for a new job not long after passing on it so dismissively.
I can see Ringo doing a good job with it… I mean, this is the man who sang ‘Yellow Submarine’ and ‘Octopuses Garden’, so it wouldn’t have been beneath him!
I grew up with Tony in my living room on his show…the guy seemed like a likable guy and Dawn I had crushes on…but no…just no. It’s the kind of song that will stick with you and roll around in your head all day…like TODAY.
When I see Tony Orlando…I think of Freddie Prinze Sr from Chico and the Man.
Yes I can see that similarity… And, yep, the song’s still there in my head this morning…
Freedie and Tony were friends and appeared with each other quite often…still in mine also
Thank you! On all counts…
It was nice the first 20 times I heard it. They wore it out in my area.
I don’t mind it, but I think even 20 times is pushing it!
This was lovely when it was fresh and new, and it spearheaded the resurgance in the movement for returning US troops from combat zones getting yellow ribbons. And then it hung around the charts for the rest of the year and outstayed it’s welcome!
If I was to be so theoretically drunk that I stood up to do public karaoke in a bar I would do this one – it’s not challenging for those of us who sing all the right notes, but not necessarily in the right order 🙂
I hadn’t realised that it was the biggest selling single of the year! But I can see why… And yes, a good karaoke choice, for the distant time when we’ll be able to gather en masse and share microphones…
Pingback: Recap: #301 – #330 – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 334. ‘Welcome Home’, by Peters and Lee – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 337. ‘Angel Fingers’, by Wizzard – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 387. ‘Save Your Kisses For Me’, by Brotherhood of Man – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 445. ‘One Day at a Time’, by Lena Martell – The UK Number Ones Blog
I really like this song. Really damn catchy. But for how big it was, it’s really been forgotten. You ask anyone under the age of 50 if they know this one, very few will say they do. I’ve noticed that for a lot of 70s pop. Most of the 70s music people remember is the classic rock, R&B, funk, soul and the disco. And ABBA for pure pop. Like, you’ll see teenagers and young adults still listen to Zeppelin, Pink Floyd, ABBA, Donna Summers, Bee Gees, etc. But 70s pop as a whole has basically been discarded from the popular mainstream, beside a few songs.
This song gets way too much hate. Tom Breihan from Stereogum in His Number One’s column gave it a 1/10, which is ridiculous (his column is great but his ratings are 50/50). Yes, it’s corny, it’s cheesy, it’s saccharine. It’s the very definition of early 70s pop that clogged the AM airwaves. But’s it’s a perfectly good song that tells a story and has a positive message.