And so we welcome to the stage a true rock icon, a man who sells albums and fills stadiums to this day. Sir Rod Stewart. (I’m assuming he’s a ‘Sir’. Sort it out, Queenie, if he isn’t.)
Maggie May / Reason to Believe, by Rod Stewart (his 1st of six #1s)
5 weeks, from 3rd October – 7th November 1971
This was his very first solo single release to make the charts. Straight to the top with a bullet, with what is his most famous song? I don’t think I’ve ever heard the ‘single’ version of ‘Maggie May’, which is a full two minutes shorter than the extended version I grew up with. It’s the same intro, albeit condensed, a confident acoustic riff, then two emphatic drumbeats announcing that the story is ready to begin. Wake up Maggie, I think I got something to say to you…
Young Rod has been seduced by an older woman, spent a summer with her, and is now starting to wake up to the harsh realities of their relationship. It’s late September and I really should be back at school… ‘Maggie May’ is famously based on Stewart’s encounter with a real woman, at a Jazz festival when he was sixteen. Getting away from the slightly predatory story – imagine if the genders were reversed – the lyrics capture perfectly the voice of a callous teen, coupled with some corny rhymes: I laughed at all your jokes, My love you didn’t need to coax… And then the classic: The morning sun when it’s in your face really shows your age… Harsh!
He loves her, but wishes he’d never seen her face. We’ve all been there. Young Rod sounds like a bit of a tearaway – his options post-Maggie are either becoming a roadie or making a living out of playing pool… I’m sure he’ll be fine, and get over the heartbreak. Anyway, the whole song is basically him rehearsing what he’s going to say to Maggie. He hasn’t broke it off just yet! It hinges on the opening and closing lines: I think I’ve got something to say to you… and I’ll get on back home, One of these days…
Unfortunately, the single version cuts the best verse, the one with the: You turned into a lover and mother what a lover you wore me out! line. Maybe that would have been too ripe for daytime radio. Then comes the solo, and the mandolin outro, one of the Celtic-sounding elements that often pop up in Rod Stewart’s music. It’s an undeniable classic, one that – cliched but true – still sounds fresh today. One that no amount of terrible pub karaoke versions can ruin. And while the woman may have been real, her name wasn’t ‘Maggie May’ – she was a famous Liverpudlian prostitute. I’m sure the actual ‘Maggie’ was delighted by the comparison…
It’s been a long old while since we had a double-‘A’ hit the top of the charts – not since Louis Armstrong in 1968. On the flip we have Rod’s cover of ‘Reason to Believe’, a song I’m certain I’ve never heard before. It opens with a lonesome piano, before the vocals come in. Both these songs are very much focused on Stewart’s voice. Which is fair enough, as he does have one of the best.
If I listen, Long enough, To you… I’d find a way, To believe, That it’s all true… In ‘Maggie May’, he was trying to convince himself to leave someone. In this song, he’s trying to talk himself into staying, despite knowing that his lover lied: straight faced, while I cried… He needs a reason to believe in her. The two songs work well together, both in terms of the sound and the lyrical theme.
A fiddle gives this record the country feel that the mandolin gave ‘Maggie May’. Then midway through, we’re left with just the voice. Someone like you, Makes it hard to live, Without, Somebody else… It’s a nice song, that slowly grows on the listener; but it’s no ‘Maggie May’. Technically, ‘Reason to Believe’ was the song first pushed to radio when the disc was released, but the song on the other side quickly won through. Maybe it was because The Carpenters had released a version of the song the year before – a classic Carpentersy-country version – while the folky original had been recorded in 1965, by Tim Hardin, that the label thought ‘Reason…’ might have caught people’s attention quicker.
For, while this was Rod Stewart’s first charting single, it wasn’t his first attempt at a solo career. He’d been releasing singles since 1964, and had spent the sixties busking, playing session gigs and jumping between bands. Then came The Jeff Beck Group, in which he met Ronnie Wood, and then The Faces (basically The Small Faces minus lead singer Steve Marriott), with whom he was having hits alongside his solo work in the early seventies. After this huge five-week #1 smash there will be no looking back for Rod – he’ll go on to become one of the decades’ biggest stars, on either side of the Atlantic, and we’ll be meeting him plenty more times in the months to come.
21 thoughts on “305. ‘Maggie May’ / ‘Reason to Believe’, by Rod Stewart”
It’s remarkable to think that a friend to whom Rod played the album prior to release (and who had wisely remained anonymous) told him that this was the one track he ought to leave off as it had no tune. And also famous for coaxing that well-known Top of the Pops hater (until he became a regular compere in 1982) John Peel to mime Ray Jackson’s mandolin part – as badly as possible. Peel was at pains to keep on the right side of the Musicians’ Union, who told him it would be OK as long as he was not seen to be getting any sound out of the instrument.
‘Not seen to be getting any sound out of it…’ How does that work!?
The number of huge hits that were almost scrapped, or turned down by others, always surprises me.
This is the time where I like Rod the Mod the best. During the Faces when the band backed him up…he should have shared some of those hits with them.
Yeah. Were The Faces playing on this one? Sad that they didn’t get the credit, if they were….
Ron Wood was playing bass and I believe Ian McLagan played keyboards.
I just wish he would have saved a few for them…they would have been remembered a little better… Soon after it was Rod Stewart and the Faces live…that didnt’ go down well at times.
I feel like in the UK the Faces are remembered, but obviously not as well as Rod or Ronnie Wood after he joined the Stones. ‘Stay With Me’ still gets played, and covered by every pub band going…
Over here they are not remembered as much as some are…and it’s a shame. They were a great band. I loved Oh La La
Both songs are awesome. I didn’t realize that The Carpenters had done “Reason…”
I wasn’t a huge fan of Maggie May at the time, in comparison to other charting stuff in the UK, but by 1976 when it charted again I was a convert, and grew to love it. I think I still prefer his next chart-topper, but it’s a close-run thing…..!
I just wrote my post on Rod’s next #1 – I like to stay a few ahead – and it’s very similar to Maggie May. Not a bad thing, but I think I prefer the ‘original’…
Pingback: 306. ‘Coz I Luv You’, by Slade – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 306. ‘Coz I Luv You’, by Slade – The UK Number Ones Blog
Really enjoy Maggie May and it’s probably the Rod Stewart song that’s well remembered today from all the times I hear it on classic rock radio. For me, it’s easily Stewart’s best song in terms of his hits before he started selling out in the late ’70s. While “Maggie May” was a similarly big hit in America, Stewart wouldn’t hit it big on the charts until 1976’s “Tonight’s The Night” which was Billboard’s biggest song of 1977 despite spending much of its #1 run at the end of ’76. After that, he’d be a reliable charting presence through the ’90s with the 1994 #1 “All For Love” with Bryan Adams and Sting. Let’s just a lot of that run doesn’t measure up to his early work.
Speaking of “Maggie May,” here’s the funny Top of the Pops performance where the band does their best to show that their performance is not live
Yes, that performance came about because the musicians union (or something similar) complained about the DJ John Peel playing one of the instruments. So to get around it, and to keep him on stage, they did that… Quite a few TOTP performances were deliberately messed up, often as a protest about the shows miming policy. Nirvana did it, and I remember Noel ‘singing’ Liam’s vocals on an Oasis hit too…
Pingback: 305. ‘Maggie May’ / ‘Reason to Believe’, by Rod Stewart – Karen O'Brien Country Music
Reason To Believe – one of THE great songs of the 20th Century. Is it possible to do a bad version of it? I don’t think so!
Pingback: 318. ‘You Wear It Well’, by Rod Stewart – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 377. ‘Sailing’, by Rod Stewart – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 405. ‘I Don’t Want to Talk About It’ / ‘The First Cut Is the Deepest’, by Rod Stewart – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 429. ‘Da Ya Think I’m Sexy?’, by Rod Stewart – The UK Number Ones Blog
Pingback: 523. ‘Baby Jane’, by Rod Stewart | The UK Number Ones Blog